"The harder path is creating a more just society..." August 20, 2011 Letter by Mary Moore

Letter To the Editor: Press Democrat  August 20, 2011

[Regarding Article "Santa Rosa Mayor Defends Kids Handling SWAT Weapons" Read below]

It is useless to try logic with people who have become so desensitized that they don't instinctively react with outrage at the idea of our local police using guns and tanks in an attempt to "reach the community" through its children via the "cool" factor as was just done in South Park.

In his letter defending the police, Mayor Ernesto Oliveres doesn't mention the "brotherhood" that exists in law enforcement culture. That usually comes out during stressful situations like the many unnessary officer involved killings of civilians across the country. Our community has seen a lot of those over the years and like clock work the "blue wall of silence" comes up. I've been part of local groups monitoring these killings since the mid '90s and in not one case was there ever a public admission that any law officer was wrong or trigger happy even when the courts later disagreed.

Using "safety" as an excuse to indoctrinate our children is a specious argument. It's the way to go if you want to further a macho gang mentality caused by racism and inequality. The harder path is creating a more just society but that won't happen by showing off your guns and power to impress.

If you really want to start a dialogue with our children then start by breaking your silence the next time one of your comrades takes an innocent life. Now, that would be impressive.

Mary Moore
August 20, 2011



Santa Rosa mayor defends kids handling SWAT weapons

Thursday, August 18th, 2011 By KEVIN McCALLUM THE PRESS DEMOCRAT

Santa Rosa Mayor Ernesto Olivares supports the decision by police to allow young children to handle fully automatic weapons during a recent community outreach event in the South Park neighborhood.

Santa Rosa police officer Perry Plattus on Saturday explained SWAT team weapons and other equipment during a community outreach event in the South Park neighborhood. (Courtesy of Attila Nagy)

The retired Santa Rosa police lieutenant said he helped organize the first such event three years ago and said it was “unfortunate” that critics have characterized the SWAT team display as inappropriate.

“They’re way off base,” Olivares said of those who suggested allowing children to handle police weapons might foster a dangerous fascination with guns.

Some residents attending South Park Day and Night Festival on Saturday took issue with the display put on by the Santa Rosa Police Department Special Weapons And Tactics team. Photos taken at the event and circulated to city council members showed a young boy holding and aiming an assault rifle and another grabbing for a riot gun. Both weapons were locked and unloaded and handled under the supervision of a SWAT team officer. An armored personnel carrier also was on display.

Attila Nagy, who took and circulated the photos, said the display of fire power and handling of weapons by children in a neighborhood that struggles with gun violence struck him as counterproductive.

”Is that supposed to make children feel secure?” Negy said. “I feel like the whole event was insensitive to the community.”

(See photos of the event)

Police Chief Tom Schwedhelm has said the goal of the display was to “demystify” the role of SWAT and tools used by officers. Doing so helps build trust between police and neighborhood residents by breaking down barriers between them, he said.

Olivares said the festival began in 2009 and was spearheaded by the Mayor’s Gang Prevention Task Force, which he ran until he retired in 2008 to run for the council. The SWAT team has been part of the event every year.

The festival was modeled after a similar program in Los Angeles that organized community events in high-crime areas, such as basketball tournaments between officers and neighborhood residents, Olivares said.

In such non-confrontational, educational settings, young people are invariably drawn to the hardware of the law enforcement trade: the badge, the handcuffs, the gun.

“The stuff attracts them,” Olivares said. “There’s still this mystique about all this stuff.”

Such interactions with young people — and often their parents, too — offer “teaching moments” that allow officers to get across important positive messages, such as the role police play in crime prevention or about gun safety, Olivares said.

As an officer raising his own children, Olivares said he made sure his daughters had the opportunity to hold his service weapon in his presence. He did so because he didn’t want them to reach for it out of curiosity when an adult wasn’t around.

He said he viewed the Saturday event as performing a similar function between SWAT officers and the families in the South Park neighborhood, with whom he says police have “ongoing relationship building.”



From: Irv Sutley Date: Sat, 20 Aug 2011 Subject: Re: Letter to the Editor Police & kids in South Park

Mayor Ernesto Olivaros as you may remember is a former police officer and is protecting his own. If an ordinary citizen who had lawfully registered a semi automatic "assault" weapon allowed someone under the age of 18 to handle such a gun without the child's parents giving written permission, the gunowner could be charged with a felony under California law. Why then can a police officer get away with letting a person under the age of 18 handle a selective fire weapon which is capable of either fully automatic fire or semi-autmatic fire without such parental release?

In a similar vein, several years ago the police in Santa Rosa arrested Food Not Bombs several times for serving hot food to the homeless in a city park yet refused to cite the Sonoma County Law Enforcement Chaplaincy program when it did the same thing without the required permits to insure the safety of prepared food. Double standards all around.

There needs to be a California Public Records Act request made of the City of Santa Rosa (and all other Sonoma jurisdictions) to find out just what weapons these government entities own and where they are acquiring them.